On Why I Keep Making A Holiday Show (a Derry honest answer)
Rehearsal, Derry-style: twenty songs, loads of fun, zero options.
I love the holidays, and the music lives in my brain all year long. Like Dickens’ Scrooge, “I will honor Christmas in my heart, and try to keep it all the year.” I sing “Winter Weather” in June. I do my “Christmas Dreaming” early and often. I can’t help it. The childhood excitement of Santa plus the whole you’d-better-be-good thing is hard-wired into my DNA.
The date of my holiday cabaret is on the calendar and the clock is ticking down. So why is my setlist so…unsettled?
Partly, it’s the endless possibilities. The world is full of good music, and my secret mission is to sing it all so you don’t miss it while we’re here on earth. (Kidding. Mostly.) It always feels a shame to me to NOT sing a song just because there isn’t space for it. I’m a big fan of the Great American Songbook, that gorgeous era of pithy, forward-moving lyrics and soaring melodies. I swoon for a Berlin ballad, and give me a deep cut by Jimmy Van Heusen or from a Kay Starr album any day. One Christmas, appropriately, my dad gave me Ben Yagoda’s The B Side, and it's a book I return to again and again. I’ve always had a soft spot for the flip side: the songs that tell a story and are achingly beautiful or full of charm and wonder, even if they’re not the hits. (And if there’s a song about a bell, even better. More on that later.)
Endless possibilities mean endless lists. When my musical director Howard Breitbart (the Bright of the title!) has time for a rehearsal, I jump at the chance and jump in the car with a list of surefire songs - so that we are purposed and use our limited time wisely. Here’s how that goes:
Susan enters, bursting with ideas falling all over herself to unpack her iPad.
Our two protagonists start AirDropping PDFs like mad. No PDFs appear.
We discover AirDrop is off, we turn it on, on our respective devices, exchange codes, again (why, Apple???), and then the PDFs fly, as do the creative juices.
We sing one thing. We love it, it’s a maybe. And then it’s a “What about..?” from Howard, or a “Have you heard…” from me, a “Let’s try…” from Howard and suddenly it's two hours later, we’ve sung through 20 things - none of which were on the original surefire list - and nothing is definite.
End scene.
But it isn’t only that I can’t bear NOT singing something. Every song must support the story in my head.
Here’s a little secret about cabarets: they can be structured any way you like. Holiday cabarets especially can have a zany, anything goes spirit: think British pantomimes, plus a dash of Weimar Zeitgeist. Even the zaniest setlist makes marvelous sense when it tells a story. It goes beyond the balance of ballad vs uptempo, Tin Pan Alley tunes vs contemporary power anthems; great artists of any stripe can make even the most seemingly disconnected choices work. Don’t judge a setlist before you hear it!
For me, the story of the setlist lives in the lyrics. They have to move me, for one, but they really have to illuminate what I’m thinking and the story I want to tell. The Derry honest part is this: I’ve been resisting what I want to say. Hence, no setlist.
This show is the culmination of my year as Cabaret Artist-in-Residence at Creative Cauldron Stage. It’s the ending of something I made, something I’ve put my heart and soul into, something that required me to risk. I am resisting the ending of this series, and I think I am resisting the reality of what passing time means: growing up, growing older; I am resisting….
And endings are scary in this business, because there is no guarantee. There is work, and there is hustle. Then more work, practice, more hustle. We are constantly readying ourselves to be ready, we share ourselves and then hope it will be received.
I did this residency to have a place to share my work and myself, and I have done exactly that, but the ending of it is sad, bittersweet, and scary, and also kind of freeing. I must remind myself it’s certainly not the last time I will do a cabaret or a holiday concert for heaven's sake - this is just a jumping off point.
It has been a year of very hard work, practice and hustle. It has been a year of many lessons learned. And it’s been a year of joy. I am more sure than ever that I’m doing the right thing - this singing thing (at your age you ask NOW you’re sure? Yes. Now. Sort of.) Artists live in this funny spot between “Wow, that was kind of great” and “geez, I think I might really be dreadful.” Some days I’m living the former. Other days I’m humming the playground standard “nobody likes me, everybody hates me, I’m gonna go eat worms.” (Could be a fun mashup with Kay Swift’s “Let’s Go Eat Worms In The Garden.” My twisted mind at work…)
I push my students to do the work of a performer from their own point of view. It’s an idea they have to grow into, and I hope I’ve grown into it this year. It’s certainly something I plan to carry into the next. Right now this work is all from my point of view: my stamp, my VOICE. And it feels right. This is what I mean by doing the right thing. It is joy, bright, bright joy.
That joy: that’s my why - for the world, for students, for me. That, and the hope, always the hope. Not just at Christmas, either. It’s the why of my work year-round. (Right, Mr. Scrooge?)
So I have to believe in the unsung songs. You may not hear all of them on December 6, but they’re there, waiting their turn. I just have to have a little faith in this voice, and in this right thing.
Mr. Sondheim’s directive to give us more to see is ever-present in my brain. I have much more to give; the ending of this residency time is immaterial. Bright on purpose is feeling all of this and choosing the joy, building the setlist anyway.
What will be on it? I can promise you one thing. There will be bells. There will not be any worms.
If you're near Falls Church, come get Derry & Bright: Sunday, December 6, 7:30pm at Creative Cauldron Stage. Live & streaming. Tickets: www.susanderry.com/tix.
What song makes your December bright?